Thursday, October 25, 2012

Reader: Road Warrior screwed up again


Rush hour on the Garden State Parkway.


Editor's note: Wednesday's front-page rewrite of a study on decals for probationary drivers was full of errors, according to a reader. Here is the reader's latest e-mail to Road Warrior John Cichowski, Editor Marty Gottlieb of The Record and others.

"John,

"The 10/24 Road Warrior column is once again preventing readers from receiving reliable, fact-based and common-sense reporting.

"Once again, you misreport and miscomprehend the facts from a recent report on the impact of NJ's decal law on crash rates for probationary drivers under 21, similar to the way I showed that you butchered and miscomprehended the facts in your 9/21 article reviewing the N.J. State Police report for fatal crashes for 2011.
 
"It does not promote the integrity of The Record and offends informative readers.

"This is the 8th article of mistaken reporting I have notified you about since your 9/12 article.  You make no attempt to correct or respond to your mistaken reporting and advice.

"No effort is being made by you or The Record to resolve these matters.


"Pretty soon, we will have a Top 10 list of Road Warrior misadventures, I mean columns, that I will publicize with other media personnel, news organizations and your readers.

"Clearly, you did not comprehend the same study, http://ajpmonline.org/webfiles/images/journals/amepre/AMEPRE_3621%5B3%5D-stamped.pdf, which you and I read.

"You leave your informative and uninformative readers in a state of confusion based on your brief study of this extensive study.

"You failed to mention that initial positive results (5/1/10 - 5/31/11) for probationary drivers in the first year after the decal law may not hold up in subsequent years, as the study clearly indicated, along with stating that further studies in future years are needed.  You were derelict to NOT mention that these initial results have also been challenged by the fact that young inexperienced drivers (20 and younger) were involved in 20.9% more fatal crashes and 64.7% more deaths in 2011 than 2010, when the decal law passed (see your inaccurate and misleading 9/21 column, which I commented on, about large increase in teenager crashes and deaths in 2011).  Fatal crash results for 2012 seem to be on same increased pace as 2011.

"The Record should correct your false statements below.


"1. Your False Statement - The study "analysis shows crashes among drivers under 21 had declined 9 percent from May 2010 to April 2011"

"CORRECT FACTS -
Study 'analysis shows crashes among probationary drivers under 21 had declined 9 percent from May 2010 to May 31,2011.'  As clearly stated on 1st page, the results focused on probationary drivers and NOT ALL drivers under 21. Probationary drivers under 21 are a much smaller subset of all drivers under 21. As clearly stated on the 2nd page, the post-[decal] law published results were for May 1, 2010 thru May 31, 2011.

"2. Your False Statement -
  '1,624 fewer crashes occurred during this period [May 2010 to April 2011] compared with monthly averages in the two prior years.'

"CORRECT FACTS - The study 'only estimated [there were] 1624 young probationary drivers for whom crashes were prevented between May 2010 to May 31, 2011 [that could be attributed due to implementation of the decal law in 2010].' This estimate was based on its statistical analysis of crash figure totals.  The study NEVER stated 1,624 fewer actual crashes occurred during this period compared to averages of the 2 prior years. As the study also indicates, actual differences between the total number of crashes for these 2 periods were influenced by many other factors beyond the decal law.

"3. Your False Statement - 'Thirteen percent of the [total] crash reduction [of 9%] was attributed to the midnight-to-5 a.m. period.'

"CORRECT FACTS -  As per the study, 'The actual rate of crashes occurring between 12:01 AM and 5:00 AM decreased 13%'.... 'Crashes that occurred during this time period comprised only 6% of all probationary drivers’ crashes.'

"4. Your False Statement - 'Besides reducing collisions by 9 percent among drivers under 21, the study showed that police issued 14 percent more tickets for violations during the first year of the decal requirement.'

"CORRECT FACTS -  'Besides reducing collisions by 9 percent among probationary drivers under 21, the study showed that police issued 14 percent more GDL tickets for violations during the first year of the decal requirement.'

"Here's hoping to change and better fact checking, corrections, and reviewing by Record's editors, columnists, and reporters, for more reliable, accurate, and common sense info prior to publication."

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Editor runs robotic rewrite on Page 1


Although the dumpsters are gone, not much has changed at The Record's old 150 River St. headquarters in Hackensack since I took this photo on a hot day this summer.



The Record's editors have given us a new breed of reporter who is skilled in rewriting press releases, studies, surveys and reports, and who thinks "legwork" is a dance routine.

Staff Writer John Cichowski -- the so-called Road Warrior -- is one of those office-loving reporters who is almost robotic in rewriting press releases or handouts, as his Page 1 column today demonstrates.

I've read the column twice, and can't find the reason crashes declined dramatically after New Jersey drivers under 21 were required to stick a red decal on their license plates.

Did the law keep many young drivers off the road altogether? Cichowski doesn't say. 

Gave voice to morons 

And the columnist doesn't take responsibility for the many negative columns he wrote about the red decals by giving voice to hysterical arguments from all those moronic parents who opposed the law.

He's been doing the same recently by quoting every lead-footed idiot he can find to blast red-light cameras, which not only cut crashes, but give cash-strapped towns a badly needed source of new revenue.

By putting Cichowski's mea culpa on Page 1 today, instead of leaving it on L-1 where it belongs, Editor Marty Gottlieb gave readers one of the most uninteresting Local fronts in memory.

A trial for readers

As usual, Head Assignment Editor Deirdre Sykes and her deputy, Dan Sforza, couldn't find any municipal news, so four of the five elements on L-1 today are Law & Order stories, and more appear inside.

It's been more than a month since any municipal news from Hackensack has appeared in Local, and I haven't seen Staff Writer Stephanie Akin's byline recently.

Could she be on vacation or does her absence have anything to do with a lawsuit The Record's parent company filed against the city, seeking unspecified documents? 

Cooking blind

In the most definitive explanation of her role since she became food editor, Susan Leigh Sherrill confesses today that she is in a dither over the stacks of free cookbooks she has to publicize (BL-1).

"So many cookbooks, so little time" is her lead sentence.

Sherrill doesn't explain how giving free publicity to cookbook writers who use butter, heavy cream and other artery clogging ingredients advances readers' desire to eat healthy.

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

National focus continues to cheat local readers

Top or Bottom
Double-decker train cars are NJ Transit's answer to continued crowding during rush hours, but riders on the upper level often hit their heads on the low, unpadded luggage rack.



Editor Marty Gottlieb's continued focus on the presidential election today and Monday is cheating local readers.

In all the stories about the presidential debate and how the candidates' environmental and education policies might impact New Jersey, a fundamental question is left unanswered:

Can voters believe anything GOP hopeful Mitt Romney is saying in view of how many times he's changed his position on nearly everything?

Readers are bombarded with polls, but where is the report on the historical accuracy of these national voter surveys?

Should Borgs step up?

The lone North Jersey story on Monday's Page 1 reports last week's Action Against Hunger Food Drive didn't set records.

The food drive is organized by the North Jersey Media Group Foundation -- the so-called charitable arm of the company that publishes The Record and Herald News.

So, maybe it's time to ask why the wealthy and influential Borg family doesn't contribute a slice of their personal income to the drive.  

If NJMG can afford to give Publisher Stephen A. Borg about $4.5 million in mortgages on two Tenafly homes in recent years, surely the Borgs can cough up some loose change for the hungry.  

One-track coverage

The lead story on Monday's local front is head Assignment Editor Deirdre Sykes' contribution to the paper's comprehensive coverage of mass transit and Hackensack.

The story -- about a 51-year-old woman killed on Saturday night by an NJ Transit train in Hackensack -- is filled with unanswered questions.

Why does NJ Transit leave unfenced block after block of track along Railroad Avenue, which runs through a residential neighborhood, and why doesn't it patrol that stretch day and night?

What kind of lighting is there at Central and Railroad avenues, where victim Leslie Seldin allegedly "went around the gates," according to NJ Transit?   

Although Seldin was killed at night, a 12-year-old middle school student also was killed by a train on Railroad Avenue on the way home from school.

He might be alive today, if Hackensack offered school busing.

Story with no ending

On today's front page, another story on recent attempts to lure children in Westwood, Maywood and other communities pussy foots around the big question:

Are local police doing enough to protect residents (A-1)?

What's up, doc?

On today's Local front, Sykes gives readers another medical miracle -- a Wallington schoolgirl who is alive today thanks to a bone-marrow transplant  from a Canadian woman.

That comes a day after the heart-warming story of a Fort Lee High School student who is raising awareness about the shortage of organ donors and organs (L-1 on Monday).

Car-crash news

Sykes and her deputy, Dan Sforza, were a little short of news and enterprise photos, hence the non-fatal accident photo used as filler on L-3 today.

The photo caption is missing the cause of the accident, the names of the drivers, their condition and what hospital is treating them. 
 Enhanced by Zemanta

Sunday, October 21, 2012

Lots of news and views, but not about you

cuba
Editor Marty Gottlieb of The Record has been focusing a lot of attention on preliminary 9/11 hearings in Cuba, not the many problems facing residents who live in North Jersey.



Editor Marty Gottlieb gives us another disappointing Sunday edition today, leading Page 1 of The Record with more on a Wayne couple's reaction to 9/11 hearings in Cuba.

The main headline says "trial," but the text reports they were "preliminary hearings." Readers remain alienated and confused.

In keeping with the media's focus on trying to predict the future, Washington Correspondent Herb Jackson does his best in a so-called ANALYSIS to guess what tax rates will be on Jan. 1.

Ultimately, the densely written, eye-glazing story produces a lot of heat, but not much light.

The only words in the story you can bank on appear in the graphic on A-8: "If Congress does nothing ..."

The vast majority of readers stare at the other three elements on Page 1 and mutter, What does that have to do with me?

Too little, too late

Head Assignment Editor Deirdre Sykes leads her Local news sections with reports on the freeholder races in Bergen and Passaic counties, but the photos and profiles come too late for 22,000 voters who received and returned mail-in ballots (L-1).

The freeholder stories would have run sooner, if the Local section didn't waste the space on all those photos showing rollover accidents on North Jersey roads and highways or downed utility poles.

Ignoring reality

Today's Road Warrior column ignores the region's traffic and mass-transit crises to answer more complaining e-mails from drivers upset with the MVC (L-1).

Friday's Road Warrior column also was based on reader e-mails, and had something to do with road signs and E-ZPass, though I just scanned it. 

Donut-hole news

New Milford Police Chief Frank Papapietro reports another luring attempt, this one at the Dunkin' Donuts on River Road, a police substation (L-1).

The drought on Hackensack municipal news continues today.

Dishing the dirt

Today's Better Living cover is dominated by The Corner Table column, which is supposed to deal with issues facing restaurant goers in North Jersey (BL-1).

Instead, Restaurant Reviewer Elisa Ung writes about three rich guys who eat out a lot and tweet about it. Who cares?

Where is Mike Kelly?

On the Opinion front, readers are told, "Record Columnist Mike Kelly is away from the office on a short leave."

That's about as hard to comprehend as one of Kelly's columns.

Did he get hit by a car? Is he ill? Or maybe he's on vacation or "investigating" something.

One thing is for sure. Few readers miss him.


Enhanced by Zemanta